Managing Multiple SSH Keys on Windows with KeePassXC and OpenSSH
Over the years I have found myself becoming a collector of SSH keys used for different systems and clients of mine. Many people will start using SSH keys having 1 key for their system, I was there myself. While SSH keys offer greater security compared to passwords, they do not offer perfect security, no solution ever will (not even this one!). There is a chance you will leak private keys (accidental GitHub commit, bad filesystem permissions, show it on a livestream, malware/trojans, and so on). Because of this, I choose to generate SSH keys for specific purposes or clients, thus limiting the “blast radius” a leaked key will have. It’s a lot easier to re-key 2 servers than 25.
Everything, we have compartmentalized our keys but now you have a new problem. Now you have become the digital equivalent of a building superintendent with massive ring of keys and no easy way to keep track of their usage.
I’m going to talk about what I’ve done to solve this issue with security in mind, without disrupting my existing workflow and using the now native Windows OpenSSH service. I wrote this guide with Windows 10/11 in mind, but should also work on Linux and MacOS OpenSSH agents.
I’ve been using KeePass for almost a decade now. I love the personal control I have over my vault, and when I started using it in 2012 most of the cloud password managers were not as strong as they are today. Nothing against them, I still advocate for Bitwarden for anyone looking at a simple cloud and free password manager. If you are debating on switching to a password manager (which by the way, you should) and don’t need crazy SSH key control, Bitwarden is fine.
KeePass being Open Source has many forks and client implementations, my favorite and choice for this being KeePassXC.
KeePassXC offers a built-in SSH Agent capable of storing your private keys inside your encrypted vault, and only presenting keys to the agent when requested. KeePassXC also offers a nice interface for auto fill browser plugins, but that is out of scope here.
I’ve been using SSH key authentication for a while now, but had limited control over my keys, defaulting to:
- Using PuTTY + Pageant + Plink
- Keeping some SSH keys in
~/.ssh/and configuring ssh-agent to read them
- Manually selecting a SSH key on every authentication
ssh -i ~/.ssh/id_client [email protected]
These solutions worked, but had some flaws:
- Required to keep SSH keys lying around on computers, some without passphrases.
- Mental gymnastics keeping track of keys + locations
- Not easily portable or synced across multiple systems. I once found myself 1000’s of miles away from home without my SSH keys to a degraded production system.
Moving to KeePassXC for SSH key management allowed me to do the following:
- Keys are centralized in 1 database. This is now 1 file to keep track of and keep safe.
- Encrypted at rest, irregardless of if passphrases are on the keys or not.
- Portable. Depending how you sync your KeePass Database, you can have all your keys on multiple machines and always up to date.
- Automation of adding/removing the keys from your systems memory when not needed.
Wait! Here Be Danger
Before we begin, a few things to keep in mind.
I will be generating new and disposable SSH keys for demonstration. NEVER show or give your private keys to anyone.
Great care should be put into protecting and backing up your KeePass database file. Unlike cloud password managers if you lose this file (or access to download it) you are hosed. You should treat this file with a 3-2-1 backup mentality. 3 Copies, 2 Locations, 1 Offline.
Download the latest KeePassXC and install.
if you already use a KeePass derivative, open your existing vault. New users can create a new vault.
Open Services in Windows. Use Search or the Run box to open
Look for “OpenSSH Authentication Agent” and set Startup type to
Automatic and start the service.
*If you Don’t have the OpenSSH Agent service, you may need to install it first.
Open the KeePassXC Settings Menu (Tools -> Settings). Select SSH Agent and enable both:
- Enable SSH Agent Integration
- Use OpenSSH for Windows instead of Pageant
For our example, let’s make a new SSH key in a CLI prompt. You can use an existing private key.
ssh-keygen.exe -t ed25519 -C "[email protected]"
Back in KeePassXC, Create a new vault entry and select
Advanced. Attach your private key to the entry.
Once attached, go to
SSH Agent and select your private key from
Attachment. The public key should now be displayed below if properly attached. Save your entry.
If your private key has a passphrase fill the password in the “Password” field, otherwise keep it blank.
For our test, we are going to check off the following options, ensuring our SSH key is only available when our password vault is unlocked.
- Add key to agent when database is opened/unlocked
- Remove key from agent when database is locked/closed
Let’s Use It
With the KeePass DB unlocked, open a command prompt and run
ssh-add -l to display keys currently in the SSH agent. You should see your public key with a matching fingerprint in KeePassXC.
Lock your KeePass database and run
ssh-add -l again. The key has been removed from your SSH agent, no longer available for use until you unlock your database again.
Following in my use case I’ve added a second key, which is also on my GitHub account. We can test our access to GitHub over SSH with
ssh -T [email protected] and see I am authenticated through my KeePass keys.
You can keep multiple keys active in your SSH agent, but without proper configuration all active keys will be tried against a host, leading to slow authentication time or fail2ban timeouts. It’s best practice to only keep your keys you need active in the SSH agent when you need them. If you only have 1-2 keys, this is not really a problem but can quickly get out of hand. Luckily, we can use our SSH config to control this.
The SSH client config file allows for easy standardization around commonly used connections. Lets take this example
ssh [email protected] -A -p 41020 -L 9906:127.0.0.1:3306 (SSH to a server as a different user, on a nonstandard port, forward the SSH agent, and tunnel MySQL back to the client). Nobody wants to type this every connection, so instead we will use the SSH config file to simplify things.
File: ~/.ssh/config host evilcorp HostName gateway-us-east1.prod.evilcorp.dev User cake ForwardAgent yes Port 41020 LocalForward 9906 127.0.0.1:3306
If we connect with
ssh -v evilcorp we get verbose output of the client/server exchange and can quickly see that our SSH agent is offering all of our keys and even looking for more, which discussed above can cause problems.
Expanding on our config above, we can add the
IdentitiesOnly directive to guide the exchange to the correct key in our agent. To do this, copy your public key out of KeePassXC to the ~/.ssh/ folder as a file. You only need to include your public key and do not put your private key in this export, or you have defeated this entire blog post.
And update your config:
File: ~/.ssh/config host evilcorp HostName gateway-us-east1.prod.evilcorp.dev User cake ForwardAgent yes Port 41020 LocalForward 9906 127.0.0.1:3306 IdentityFile ~/.ssh/id_evilcorp.pub IdentitiesOnly yes
Now if we
ssh -v evilcorp we can see a single key offered and accepted in the exchange. No more login failed noise! Your Security Operations Center thanks you :)
It’s worth nothing that even when limiting your SSH identity to a single key when signing in, if
ForwardAgent yes or
ssh -A is used, you will still forward all keys in your agent. You should only use SSH agent forwarding on servers you trust as rogue admins or compromised servers can use your agent to impersonate you while connected.
Windows native support for SSH has come a long way, and the days of needing PuTTY + Pageant + Plink are long gone. Coupling KeePassXC for secure private key storage with native OpenSSH tooling is a strong beast, allowing quick workflows to develop without compromising on security. Fumbling through KeePass documentation and StackOverflow posts on SSH configs was frustrating, I hope my guide changes that.